Mallace vs GitHub Copilot Autofix
Copilot Autofix suggests fixes for CodeQL code scanning alerts inside GitHub. Mallace proves each bug with a failing regression test before it writes a fix, then opens a pull request containing both. They solve overlapping problems in different ways, and some teams use both.
- What it fixes
- MallaceFindings from its own focused ruleset: SQL, command and code injection, and unsafe deserialization
- GitHub Copilot AutofixAlerts from CodeQL code scanning (a subset of CodeQL queries)
- Languages
- MallacePython, JavaScript, TypeScript, PHP, Ruby, Go
- GitHub Copilot AutofixC#, C/C++, Go, Java/Kotlin, Swift, JavaScript/TypeScript, Python, Ruby, Rust
- Proof before fixing
- MallaceWrites a regression test and runs it against your code; only failing tests count as real bugs
- GitHub Copilot AutofixNot described in GitHub’s documentation; GitHub tests suggestions internally before showing them
- Checking the fix
- MallaceThe same test must pass, the code must compile, and an independent model must approve
- GitHub Copilot AutofixGitHub advises you to check that CI passes before merging
- How you get the fix
- MallaceA pull request per verified fix, including the test, plus an issue
- GitHub Copilot AutofixA suggested change on the alert or pull request that you commit
- Where it runs
- MallaceYour GitHub Actions runners; only the code around each finding goes to the Mallace service
- GitHub Copilot AutofixGitHub’s platform, as part of code scanning
- Pricing model
- MallaceFree plan, or $29/month flat per account (not per developer)
- GitHub Copilot AutofixIncluded with GitHub Code Security for private repositories; see GitHub’s pricing
| Aspect | Mallace | GitHub Copilot Autofix |
|---|---|---|
| What it fixes | Findings from its own focused ruleset: SQL, command and code injection, and unsafe deserialization | Alerts from CodeQL code scanning (a subset of CodeQL queries) |
| Languages | Python, JavaScript, TypeScript, PHP, Ruby, Go | C#, C/C++, Go, Java/Kotlin, Swift, JavaScript/TypeScript, Python, Ruby, Rust |
| Proof before fixing | Writes a regression test and runs it against your code; only failing tests count as real bugs | Not described in GitHub’s documentation; GitHub tests suggestions internally before showing them |
| Checking the fix | The same test must pass, the code must compile, and an independent model must approve | GitHub advises you to check that CI passes before merging |
| How you get the fix | A pull request per verified fix, including the test, plus an issue | A suggested change on the alert or pull request that you commit |
| Where it runs | Your GitHub Actions runners; only the code around each finding goes to the Mallace service | GitHub’s platform, as part of code scanning |
| Pricing model | Free plan, or $29/month flat per account (not per developer) | Included with GitHub Code Security for private repositories; see GitHub’s pricing |
Information about GitHub Copilot Autofix comes from its own public documentation, checked November 2026. Products change: check the sources below for current details.
When Copilot Autofix is the better fit
You already run CodeQL, your code is in a language Mallace doesn’t cover yet, or you want fixes across CodeQL’s much larger set of queries. GitHub’s coverage is far broader than Mallace’s today.
When Mallace is the better fit
Your code is Python, JavaScript, TypeScript, PHP or Ruby, and you want each security fix to arrive with proof: a regression test that failed on your code before the fix and passes after. That test stays in your repository, so the bug can’t quietly come back. Mallace’s flat price can also be simpler for small teams than per-committer licensing.
Using both
They don’t conflict. Mallace skips findings that already have an open Mallace pull request, and its PRs are ordinary pull requests that CodeQL and your CI check like any other change.
Sources
See also: all comparisons · FAQ · pricing.
Try Mallace next to GitHub Copilot Autofix.
Scanning is free and unlimited, and the Free plan includes proved fixes on one repository.